Howard Hanna’s HannaList: A New Inflection Point in the Battle Over Listing Data
Industry veteran Russ Cofano says staged listing strategies reflect growing tensions over listing data, portals and brokerage control.
The real estate industry is witnessing a significant strategic shift, as Howard Hanna, the nation’s largest independent brokerage, launches its own private listing network. This move introduces “HannaList,” a platform that allows agents and their clients to share listings internally prior to broader distribution through the multiple listing service (MLS). The strategy mirrors a staged marketing approach popularized by Compass, beginning with brokerage-only exposure before moving to public marketing. With a major player of Howard Hanna’s scale and geographic reach—operating across 15 states with strong Midwest and Mid-Atlantic market share—adopting this model, observers suggest the concept may be transitioning from a single-company experiment to an industry-wide trend.
“It’s really not private versus public, it’s degrees of exposure,” said Russ Cofano, a longtime industry executive and entrepreneur, in an interview with Inman. Cofano frames the development as the latest evolution in a long-running debate over listing distribution control. Historically, brokerages controlled their own networks until the rise of the MLS system created an “all-or-nothing” model where a listing was either fully shared or not. Now, advancements in proprietary technology are enabling large brokerages to reintroduce phased exposure while still complying with MLS rules.
The Staged Marketing Playbook Gains Traction
Howard Hanna’s adoption of a phased marketing strategy is particularly notable given its status as the largest family-owned brokerage in the U.S., a distinction CEO Hoby Hanna has frequently highlighted in contrast to publicly traded or private equity-backed firms. While Compass has been the most vocal advocate for private exclusives, especially in dense urban markets, HannaList demonstrates that similar tactics are being deployed by another major brokerage with substantial inventory.
This trend extends beyond these two firms. Other brokerages have launched comparable programs, including Douglas Elliman’s Private Listings, Corcoran Reserve, and private-exclusive offerings used by some Sotheby’s International Realty affiliates and Long & Foster. The common thread is a desire to create an element of exclusivity during the initial marketing phase, which can be a powerful tool in a market characterized by tight inventory and intense competition for listings.
Data Control and the ‘Sick’ Brokerage Economics
Underlying the push for staged marketing is a deeper tension over listing data ownership and monetization. Cofano directly references the industry’s Clear Cooperation Rule, which mandates that listings be shared with the MLS within a certain timeframe after public marketing begins. He argues that while intended to foster cooperation, the rule effectively enabled portals like Zillow to aggregate and monetize brokerage-generated listing data, building multibillion-dollar businesses on the back of broker work.
“The result of Clear Cooperation was that Zillow had the ability to monetize the listing work of these companies and create a multibillion-dollar business around it,” Cofano explained. “Now brokerages are saying, ‘Time out — that’s our asset.’” This sentiment drives the exploration of strategies like HannaList, which allow brokerages to retain more control over their data’s initial dissemination and value.
Cofano also connects these moves to fundamental brokerage economics. “The brokerage industry is a sick industry economically,” he stated, pointing to persistent profitability challenges. “We need to figure out a way to help the brokerage industry be less sick from an economic standpoint.” Staged marketing programs can serve dual purposes: they offer agents a competitive edge in securing listings and can function as a recruitment and retention tool for top producers. “When you scrape off the window dressing, brokerage comes down to recruiting, retention and helping agents be more productive,” Cofano said.
Will the Strategy Spread? Industry Questions Remain
The potential for broader adoption is a key watchpoint. Industry leaders are examining whether similar tools could eventually appear across large franchise networks following Compass’s acquisition of Anywhere Real Estate, which owns brands like Coldwell Banker, Century 21, and Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate. An early indicator emerged in Chicago after Compass acquired @properties, where company founders publicly advocated for greater seller flexibility in pre-MLS marketing.
Despite the momentum, Cofano notes the industry has not reached a consensus on the optimal balance between exclusive and open marketing. He acknowledges the complexity of the issue, even admitting personal inclination: “I don’t know if I have the answer… if I were running a brokerage, I would likely be exploring similar strategies.” For now, experimentation appears to be the prevailing mode as brokerages navigate competing pressures of data control, agent needs, and market realities.
Email AJ LaTrace
